Hello,

I was looking at my ratings and was rather stunned to see that you gave me a rating of 1 for my efforts on your dissertation. I asked Patti whether she thought I should ask you about it and she said that was fine.

I have never received such a low rating and, in fact, have only received anything below a 4 on two occasions.

I was interested to know what distressed you so  much about my work. All I can imagine is that you expected only mechanical editing, rather than any critique of content or organization.

I would be interested to hear your thoughts on the subject.

Best Regards,

Nyanidoc